CHAPTER I: WOMAN'S ERROR AND HER DEBT
THE most far-reaching social development of modern times is the revolt
of woman against sex servitude. The most important force in the remaking of the world
is a free motherhood. Beside this force, the elaborate international programmes of modern
statesmen are weak and superficial. Diplomats may formulate leagues of nations and nations
may pledge their utmost strength to maintain them, statesmen may dream of reconstructing
the world out of alliances, hegemonies and spheres of influence, but woman, continuing
to produce explosive populations, will convert these pledges into the proverbial scraps
of paper; or she may, by controlling birth, lift motherhood to the plane of a voluntary,
intelligent function, and remake the world. When the world is thus remade, it will exceed
the dream of statesman, reformer and revolutionist.
Only in recent years has woman's position as the gentler and weaker
half of the human family been emphatically and generally questioned. Men assumed that
this was woman's place; woman herself accepted it. It seldom occurred to anyone to ask
whether she would go on occupying it forever.
Upon the mere surface of woman's organized protests there were no indications
that she was desirous of achieving a fundamental change in her position. She claimed
the right of suffrage and legislative regulation of her working hours, and asked that
her property rights be equal to those of the man. None of these demands, however, affected
directly the most vital factors of her existence. Whether she won her point or failed
to win it, she remained a dominated weakling in a society controlled by men.
Woman's acceptance of her inferior status was the more real because
it was unconscious. She had chained herself to her place in society and the family through
the maternal functions of her nature, and only chains thus strong could have bound her
to her lot as a brood animal for the masculine civilizations of the world. In accepting
her role as the "weaker and gentler half," she accepted that function. In turn,
the acceptance of that function fixed the more firmly her rank as an inferior.
Caught in this "vicious circle," woman has, through her reproductive
ability, founded and perpetuated the tyrannies of the Earth. Whether it was the tyranny
of a monarchy, an oligarchy or a republic, the one indispensable factor of its existence
was, as it is now, hordes of human beings; human beings so plentiful as to be cheap,
and so cheap that ignorance was their natural lot. Upon the rock of an unenlightened,
submissive maternity have these been founded; upon the product of such a maternity have
No despot ever flung forth his legions to die in foreign conquest, no
privilege-ruled nation ever erupted across its borders, to lock in death embrace with
another, but behind them loomed the driving power of a population too large for its boundaries
and its natural resources.
No period of low wages or of idleness with their want among the workers,
no peonage or sweatshop, no child-labor factory, ever came into being, save from the
same source. Nor have
famine and plague been as much "acts of God" as acts of too
prolific mothers. They, also, as all students know, have their basic causes in over-population.
The creators of over-population are the women, who, while wringing their
hands over each fresh horror, submit anew to their task of producing the multitudes who
will bring about the next tragedy of civilization.
While unknowingly laying the foundations of tyrannies and providing
the human tinder for racial conflagrations, woman was also unknowingly creating slums,
filling asylums with insane, and institutions with other defectives. She was replenishing
the ranks of the prostitutes, furnishing grist for the criminal courts and inmates for
prisons. Had she planned deliberately to achieve this tragic total of human waste and
misery, she could hardly have done it more effectively.
Woman's passivity under the burden of her disastrous task was almost
altogether that of ignorant resignation. She knew virtually nothing about her reproductive
nature and less about the consequences of her excessive childbearing. It is true that,
obeying the inner urge of their natures, some women revolted, They went even to
the extreme of infanticide and abortion. Usually their revolts were not general enough.
They fought as individuals, not as a mass. In the mass they sank back into blind and
hopeless subjection. They went on breeding with staggering rapidity those numberless,
undesired children who become the clogs and the destroyers of civilizations.
Today, however, woman is rising in fundamental revolt. Even her efforts
at mere reform are, as we shall see later, steps in that direction. Underneath each of
them is the feminine urge to complete freedom. Millions of women are asserting their
right to voluntary motherhood. They are determined to decide for themselves whether they
shall become mothers, under what conditions and when. This is the fundamental revolt
referred to. It is for woman the key to the temple of liberty.
Even as birth control is the means by which woman attains basic freedom,
so it is the means by which she must and will uproot the evil she has wrought through
her submission. As she has unconsciously and ignorantly brought about social disaster,
so must and will she consciously and intelligently undo that disaster and create
a new and a better order.
The task is hers. It cannot be avoided by excuses, nor can it be delegated.
It is not enough for woman to point to the self-evident domination of man. Nor does it
avail to plead the guilt of rulers and the exploiters of labor. It makes no difference
that she does not formulate industrial systems nor that she is an instinctive believer
in social justice. In her submission lies her error and her guilt. By her failure to
withhold the multitudes of children who have made inevitable the most flagrant of our
social evils, she incurred a debt to society. Regardless of her own wrongs, regardless
of her lack of opportunity and regardless of all other considerations, she must
pay that debt.
She must not think to pay this debt in any superficial way. She cannot
pay it with palliatives; with child-labor laws, prohibition, regulation of prostitution
and agitation against war. Political nostrums and social panaceas are but incidentally
and superficially useful. They do not touch the source of the social disease.
War, famine, poverty and oppression of the workers will continue while
woman makes life cheap. They will cease only when she limits her reproductivity and human
life is no longer a thing to be wasted.
Two chief obstacles hinder the discharge of this tremendous obligation.
The first and the lesser is the legal barrier. Dark-Age laws would still deny to her
the knowledge of her reproductive nature. Such knowledge is indispensable to intelligent
motherhood and she must achieve it, despite absurd statutes and equally absurd moral
The second and more serious barrier is her own ignorance of the extent
and effect of her submission. Until she knows the evil her subjection has wrought to
herself, to her progeny and to the world at large, she cannot wipe out that evil.
To get rid of these obstacles is to invite attack from the forces of
reaction which are so strongly entrenched in our present-day society. It means warfare
in every phase of her life. Nevertheless, at whatever cost, she must emerge from her
ignorance and assume her responsibility.
She can do this only when she has awakened to a knowledge of herself
and of the consequences of her ignorance. The first step is birth control. Through birth
control she will attain to voluntary motherhood. Having attained this, the basic freedom
of her sex, she will cease to enslave herself and the mass of humanity. Then, through
the understanding of the intuitive forward urge within her, she will not stop at patching
up the world; she will remake it.
<--warning - avertissement | <--index | -->next chapter